If you track back through the rough patch of Standard over the past two or three years and the lack of hate cards, the path will lead you to one place: the end of core sets
While not as popular at the time, this card now sells for nearly $6,000
Basil, Disguised Detective Enchanted Rare, 212/204 Up until the Disney Renaissance, which began in 1989, the animation studios 80s output had mostly underperformed, both critically and commercially
You have fought with your sister, but she is still your sister
So that $95 current selling price on average is definitely understandable, especially when you factor in the usual, high standard of card art
60-card casual decks are probably going to opt for something cheaper, like Animate Dead, or more something more powerful, like Unburial Rites