2006: Dread Return from Time Spiral At first glance, Dark Depths seems like the easy pick for most broken card of 2006, considering its power in Legacy and its ability to make a 20/20 indestructible flying Marit Lage token as early as Turn 2
Signets or Talisman take your pick
Three mana is toeing the line but in an acceptable place
Order of Sacred Dusk also isn't bad on its own, but in a deck that wants to swing with an army of Vampires and Demons, exalted isn't exactly a great keyword to give the team
Definitely more nuanced than some eldrazi that you just cast and blast players, so if you can line things up a bit, going off with Emrakul is cool
RELATED: MTG: Tales of Middle-Earth's Mount Doom Card Tells an Epic Story MTG's One Ring Is Surprisingly Easy to Get Wizards of the Coast printed a unique "one of one" serialized version of The One Ring card with authentic Elven script, stunning alternate artwork and a unique frame