mtg cards with buyback Best in (2026) — Top Picks for Commander & Beyond Buyback | Magic: The Gathering

This can be seen above scrolling list of Planeswalkers and to the left of the View All button

While there is the downside of not triggering enters and leaves abilities, being able to essentially save a creature you have in a moment of crisis isnt to be underestimated

This Naya aura gets bonus points in decks that care about enchantments, like with Preston Garvey, Minuteman

Note that colorless topdeck manipulation like Scroll Rack and Sensei's Divining Top help to get the most from Cait Sith

This card may whiff if the only creature found is a costly beater that can't be cast earlier in the game

A large range, but its up to you